‘Marriage under Sharia’ permits child prostitution

My first law of human-dynamics is:  if a law can be abused, it will!

That is why every law must be examined very, very carefully; all the ways it can be perverted and abused must be considered and weighed.  This should – preferebly – be done before such a law is accepted and before it becomes the norm in a society.

Sharia is based on the Koran and the Sunnah (the ways of the Prophet Muhammad).  It governs every aspect of a person’s life.  Here is the definition of Sharia from the Islamic Dictionary:

“Way to the water.” The “way” of Islam in accord with the Qur’an and Sunna, ijma’ and qiyas. Sharia is the law of Islam. It is based on the teachings of the Qur’an and the Sunna, though there are many sources outside these two, such as Arab Bedouin law, commercial law from Mecca, and the law of some conquered nations such as Roman and Jewish law. The Sharia extends beyond what Westerners consider law. It covers the totality of religious, political, social, including private life and makes no distinction between sin and law.

While there are several ‘schools’ of Sharia, they all have the same roots and tend to be considered complementary of each other, rather than in opposition to each other.  And, they are in agreement on many of the most fundamental rules of human behaviour and social organization.

One thing that is troubling about ‘Sharia Courts’ is that there is no formal differentiation between these various legal interpretations of the Islamic laws:  rather, it is the leadership of the local Mosque which determines what ‘school’ of Sharia applies to the congregation.  If a change occurs in the leadership (or ‘elders’) in the Mosque, the legal standards are automatically changed, without any notice being given to the populace.

It is my conviction that Aisha Ibrahim Dhuhulow was a victim of such a change.  She grew up under the interpretation of Sharia where rapists were caught and punished.  That is why, after this 13-year-old child was raped, she went to her local officials and ‘demanded that justice be done’.  Unbeknown to her, her town Mosque was recently taken over by officials who subscribed to the most extreme form of Sharia, where the rape victim is stoned to death for adultery.  That explains why she kept begging for her life and calling for help, while the officials who sentenced her to death praised her for ‘demanding that justice according to Sharia be done’…

Both courses of action are possible under different schools of Sharia!  How was the child to know that things could change THAT drastically?!?!?

Which brings me back to my original statement:  if a law can be abused, it will!

Now, I would like to ask you to consider  the rules which govern marriage under Sharia:  I have posted some of the major rules here and here. And, human nature being what it is, I would like you to consider the most twisted possible interpretation of these rules which will not be breaking the letter of the rules.  Because, sooner or later, that is exactly how every law will be applied.  (The background information is in my two earlier posts on this, linked at the beginning of this post).

The example of Muhammad, the Prophet:

  • Muslims emulate the behaviour of Prophet Muhammad, because Islam teaches that they are supposed to do that in order to lead good and pious lives.
  • Muhammad had married his ‘only virgin wife’, Aisha, when she was 6 years old (thought he waited until she was 8 (or 9 – the lunar year calculations are a little different from the solar ones)).  Therefore, that is the example that all Muslims are taught to emulate.
  • Therefore, most countries governed by Sharia allow – nay, encourage – marrying girls of  ‘Aisha’s age’.

‘Age of consent’ in the Koran:

  • Neither the Koran, nor the Sunnah, specify what is the minimum age for a person (male or female) to enter into marriage.  Therefore, there is no prohibition against very young people entering into marriage.
  • In order to ensure adequate protection of the ‘fair sex’, females – both children and adult women – have male guardians to look after them.  A girl/woman’s first guardian is her father, then her husband, her brother, and, eventually, her son.  As such, this guardian represents the girl/woman’s interests in all legal matters, such as management of property and conracts, like marriage and divorce.
  • The Koran has very specific laws about divorce.  IVery specific rules are set out in order to ensure that a husband retains control of any offspring sired – but not yet born – at the time of divorce.
  • Among these rules are ‘special cases’ for widdows, as well as for divorce from women who are no longer fertile because they have reached menopause or because they have not yet reached sexual maturity.
  • Putting these things together, the majority of Muslim scholars support the marriage of pre-pubescent girls, provided her father/guardian permits the marriage.  Some assert that ‘sexual enjoyment’ is permitted with females as young as one day old, though penetration is not ‘recommended’ (but not forbidden).
  • Following a divorce, the guardianship of the girl/woman reverts back to her father – or her closest male relative, who is free to (and encouraged to) arrange the next marriage for the girl/woman in question.

‘Bride Price’

  • Many Muslim scholars do not like the term ‘Bride Price’ – it is supposed to be a ‘nest-egg’ to support the wife in the case of divorce, until her guardian can arrange another marriage for her.  In practice, however, that is exactly what it is.
  • The size of this ‘present’ is usually set by the bride’s father or guardian, who arranges the marriage.

Hmmm…  is it really that difficult to see how this can be (and is) exploited for prostituting children?

add to del.icio.usDigg itStumble It!Add to Blinkslistadd to furladd to ma.gnoliaadd to simpyseed the vineTailRank

6 Responses to “‘Marriage under Sharia’ permits child prostitution”

  1. juggernaut Says:

    when do we debate next?

    Xanthippa says:
    IF there is still interest, I would like to go on to have some more live debates on BlogTV. ‘Holiday weekends’ are probably not the best…I know I will have a lot of obligations.

    Do you think people would be interested?

    If anyone is, please, let me know preferred times: weekend mornings or evenings (Eastern Time)? I suspect there are people in both Eastern and Western coast of North America who might be tempted into joining in…

    Methinks the topics will suggest themselves… Though, the debate was not very lively when we all agreed on points…so, perhaps, the topics are open to suggestion as well. Or, I could just be ‘contrary’ and poke holes in everyone else’s arguments, regardless of my personal POV… Or, we could just ‘play it by ear’!

    Recently, I got a hold of ‘Blue Planet in Green Shackles: What is endangered, climate or freedom’ by Vaclav Klaus – completely different angle on the whole ‘AGW alarmism’ condemnation… Much food for thought there!

    To sum up: I welcome suggestions!

  2. juggernaut Says:

    I think I know a few people who I could invite. I will probably join a few certain message boards to spread the word about this, also.

    I have been thinking of/debating on a multitude of topics. Female rights in the middle-east and autism/aspergers, we both seem to have strong idea/opinions for solutions there.
    I am also interested in debating environmental factors such as the morbidly high population increase, pollution, deforestation, climate change, agriculture, and most importantly energy independence (wind/solar/nuclear/etc.). I recently took an interest in human psychology and etymology/world languages.

    I’m proposing that we continue to live debate, to allow our live blogs to gain momentum. It may be a slow ride, but I’d hate to see a good idea go to waste.

    -JN

  3. Fun With Rape « Canucki Jihad Says:

    […] ITEM: ‘Marriage under Sharia’ permits child prostitution. Some YouTube […]

  4. Steynian 344 « Free Canuckistan! Says:

    […] XANTHIPPA– ‘Marriage under Sharia’ permits child prostitution; Marriage under Sharia; Marriage […]

  5. Mike Machine Says:

    Juhu endlich habe bei dir hier in dem Post genau das gefunden was ich gesucht habe. Ich dachte schon das ich im Inet nix mehr finde und bin beinahe verzweifelt. Aber jetzt bin ich erst mal froh vielen dank noch einmal.

  6. A look at Sharia as the parallel legal system in Indonesia « Xanthippa's Chamberpot Says:

    […] Sharia permits child prostitution – as long as the clergy gets its cut.  This accommodation to Sharia strips each and every female child born to a Muslim family of any legal protection from being forcibly married or forced into child prostitution… […]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: